No Games, No Gimmicks: Genuine Factory Direct Savings, No Markup!


Your Cart is Empty

Icon of two conversation bubbles, one with a question mark symbolizing queries and the other filled with lines, indicating responses, for our FAQ section.Flexible Financing with ShopPay. Enjoy Your Mattress Now and Pay Later.



When it comes to finding the good mattress nearby, shoppers have a plethora of options. Before heading straight to the locally owned and operated Jamestown Mattress, known for its high-quality, Western New York-crafted beds, consider visiting these five standout stores. Each offers a unique shopping experience and an impressive selection could help you make an informed decision.

Buffalo skyline at night, lights reflecting on water, with 'Metro Mattress New York' overlay.

A staple in upstate New York since 1978, Metro Mattress has expanded its reach to over 50 stores. Known for offering a vast array of top national brands such as Tempur-Pedic, Sealy, Spring Air, and Chattam & Wells, shoppers can explore a broad selection of mattresses. With flexible hours and operations seven days a week, Metro Mattress is a convenient and reliable option for any Buffalo resident.
2625 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
(716) 875-8500

Aerial view of Downtown Buffalo with 'Xtreme Discount Mattress New York' across the image.

For those looking for affordability without the name brand price, Xtreme Discount Mattress is a must-visit. President George Costello, often seen and heard in local media, promotes the store's commitment to providing spec-for-spec quality that rivals big brand names. Their diverse inventory includes innerspring and hybrid mattresses, along with memory foam and talalay latex options.
3514 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
(716) 689-5939

Distant view of Downtown Buffalo at sunset with fluffy clouds, 'City Mattress Hamburg, NY' caption.

With a history spanning over 50 years and stores across New York and Florida, City Mattress prides itself on being part of the community. Their selection is not limited to mattresses; they also offer adjustable beds, pillow tops, sleeper sofas, and linens. Carrying popular brands like PranaSleep, Tempur-Pedic, Nectar, and Stearns & Foster, City Mattress caters to a variety of tastes and budgets.
4154 McKinley Parkway, Hamburg, NY 14075
(716) 649-2922

City skyline at dusk viewed from Lake Erie, labeled 'Raymour & Flanigan Cheektowaga NY'.

Located conveniently near the Walden Galleria mall on Union Road in Cheektowaga, Raymour & Flanigan offers more than just mattresses. This store is known for its quality selection of bedroom, dining room, and living room furniture. Mattress brands like Tempurpedic, Avocado, Aireloom, Nectar, and more are available, making it a popular destination for those looking to upgrade more than just their mattress. Shopping conveniences such as interior design consultations enhance the experience.
3770 Union Road, Cheektowaga, NY 14225
(716) 391-5540

Downtown from Lake Erie with overlay 'Lake Effect Furniture and Mattress Store Cheektowaga New York'.

From humble beginnings in 2011 with grassroots advertising like handwritten signs and Craigslist postings, Lake Effect Furniture and Mattress has grown significantly. Now located on Union Road in a spacious 8,000 square foot showroom, they offer a wide selection of mattresses from brands such as Malouf, Restonic, Serta, Ashley, and Simmons. Known for their growth through word of mouth, they provide a personalized shopping experience with a community feel.
3637 Union Road Cheektowaga, NY 14225
(716) 775-7077
Visiting these stores will give you a comprehensive view of the mattress options available in Buffalo, allowing you to compare different styles, brands, and prices. Once you've explored these stores, Jamestown Mattress awaits with its locally made, quality two-sided mattresses, crafted with care right here in Western New York. Happy mattress hunting!

Contact Us

Have a question, comment, or need assistance? We're here to help! Please fill out the form, and we'll get back to you as soon as possible.